Find the best Closed Captioning Software

As the video content creation space continues to grow, it’s important to adopt the best practices, tips, and trends. If you are looking to add value to your videos by adding subtitles or transcription text, closed captioning software is here to help. It provides a visual aid to people who are deaf or have a weak hearing ability. A closed captioning software usually provides both real-time subtitles for live events and pre-recorded captioning for pre-recorded shows, videos, movies, games, etc.

The solution is used by creative, marketing, and production teams in an organization whose goal is to ensure maximum comprehension and high video engagement. Marketing strategies across major industries often involve video content, which should be both inclusive and accessible to the audience. Accurate captioning is an inclusive step which can serve the people who are hard of hearing or deaf.

There are many options available on the market which makes it difficult in deciding which software to purchase. In this buyers guide, we’ve provided all the information you need to make the right purchase decision for your closed captioning solution.

Here’s what we'll cover:

• What is closed captioning software?

• Common features of closed captioning software

• What type of buyer are you?

• Benefits of closed captioning software

• Key considerations when purchasing closed captioning software

• Market trends to understand

What is closed captioning software?

A closed captioning solution provides users with the tools for converting text-to-speech. It has various applications across industries. It can be used by organizations for capturing meeting notes, ideas, or memos from recordings which can be shared in a text format using email or evernote. It allows businesses in entertainment, education, and government sectors to streamline speech recognition, transcription, and closed captioning processes.

The closed captioning software assists professionals by transforming picture and video content in multiple languages. Users can add a specific set of details to the transcript such as names and numbers of speakers, manner of speech, and language being used. This software solution often provides integration capabilities with third party platforms such as Vimeo, Facebook, Canvas, Google Drive and more to store and manage files.

Caption editor in Rev Software (Source)

Common features of closed captioning software

Most closed captioning systems have the following features in common:

What type of buyer are you?

Most buyers of closed captioning platform belong to either of the following categories:

• For businesses in the education and e-learning industry: Buyers in this category tend to seek software that is easy to use and navigate. They look for solutions that provide accuracy while being cost-effective. Their priority is that the solution should comply with ADA and all those laws that provide digital accessibility or inclusion to the deaf and hard-of-hearing people.

• For businesses in media/entertainment: These buyers look for software that can quickly process videos and have quicker turnaround times, as their needs are dynamic and evolving in nature. They often need tools that offer multiple file format support as they require the video caption to be compatible with multiple applications. They look for integration capabilities so that they can save time to publish/contribute captions to the video content.

• For businesses in event production: These buyers manage content that could either be pre-recorded or live. They look for a solution that can simplify the workflow through automations. They need a solution for making Zoom meetings, virtual conferences, and other online events successful by providing everyone with access to the audio/video content in the form of supporting text. Buyers in this category look for live transcription capabilities in the software.

• For businesses in corporates/enterprise: These buyers look for software that can cater to their demand for multiple clients. Such buyers usually consider a platform which offers various caption formats, provide integration and open API capabilities, and maintain an ADA-compliant transcription process. These buyers cater to large audiences and users which could be their clients, employees, or end-users.

Benefits of closed captioning software

• Improved indexing for search engine optimization: Google spiders, also known as Google bots, are constantly indexing pages from Google. But they cannot see or hear a video, which leads to web content going unnoticed because of improper indexing issues. Adding caption text to your videos solves this problem and provides your video content with a better ranking and more searchability. Which in turn, helps drive more traffic and engagement to your business.

• Captioning the videos is often a legal requirement: There are laws in the United States, including Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) which requires universities and colleges to include closed captions in their videos, such as online courses, recorded lectures, or any other video content being used for teaching purposes. This provides equal opportunity to those who have hearing loss and need captions to participate in class at the same level as their peers.

• Wider reach to non-native speakers: It can become a challenge for someone to understand what the other person is saying because of the speaker’s dialect or accent. There could be a scenario where the viewer has an understanding of the language but is still struggling to follow the words spoken in the video. Video captioning widens the content reach to viewers across different languages.

Here are a few things to keep in mind when purchasing a closed captioning software:

• Accurate closed captions: As per the industry standards, a closed captioning service provider is required to produce 99% accurate results. Spelling, grammar, and punctuation are all part of accuracy calculations. This means that per 1000 words, there is leniency of 1% error, or 10 words. Check how a vendor measures its accuracy. For example, asking your vendor questions such as: What percentage accuracy does your platform offer? Is the accuracy the same for every caption file? Inaccurate captions could lead to miscomprehension of the message.

• Described and Captioned Media Program (DCMP): The standard defines a set of guidelines as best practices. DCMP philosophy states that the captions should be accurate, consistent, clear, readable, and equal. Whether the software is processing the automatic captioning for a video file or for a live stream, following this standard set of rules ensures that the meaning and intent of the message should remain intact.

• 3Play standardization: Legal standards for captioning processes can be vague, 3play standard defines the captions to have good readability, timely caption placement, and should have proper speaker labels. For example, readability of a caption includes parameters like characters per line, timely synchronization, which is 3 to 7 seconds of display of text on screen. Proper speaker labels such as name of the speaker involved should be used, or generic labels such as “student”, “teacher”, and “speaker” should be used.

• Support for various caption file formats: There are numerous closed caption formats available today. And every format has its unique purpose and usability. You may want to have a specific set of file support for your business. Checking this information beforehand could be handy as your business grows. For example, “SubRip Subtitle” file or commonly known as “.srt” is accepted by many media players and applications such as Facebook, YouTube, Kature, and more. Another file type ““Web Video Text Tracks,” or a .vtt file is used for cloud-based videos and accommodates rendering options, audio description, and text formatting and positioning. Another file format “.cap” is widely used for storing the characters in various languages to be used across countries.

Market trends to understand

• Artificial Intelligence (AI) will impact the digital product teams: According to Gartner, the generative AI revolution will benefit organizations in digital production (full content available to Gartner clients). AI will help the video editor and video creator determine on-screen designs, content types, and help in generating captions in less time and with more accuracy. Companies are shifting their focus from manual to automation of processes. Such caption generating solutions will improve their turnaround times.

Note: The applications mentioned in this article are examples to show a feature in context and are not intended as endorsements or recommendations. They have been obtained from sources believed to be reliable at the time of publication.