All Advantage Reviews
1-25 of 38 Reviews
Sort by
Steve
Verified reviewer
51-200 employees
Used daily for more than 2 years
OVERALL RATING:
5
EASE OF USE
5
VALUE FOR MONEY
5
CUSTOMER SUPPORT
5
FUNCTIONALITY
5
Reviewed May 2018
Excellent core app for us. Team loves it. Outstanding technical support.
Project management, accounting, workflow, routing, expenses, time tracking.
PROSOur entire team on one platform for projects + accounting? And people love it? Is...such a thing even possible? It is - and it is Advantage. Having worked with Quickbooks, Netsuite, Sage, Foundation and all manner of home-grown horrors... Advantage is a wondrous breath of fresh air. I'm the IT Director and have not had a single incident or technical issue with Advantage (beyond your occasional password reset). The times that I have reached out to technical support have been largely for information / usage questions as I learned. They greeted us, recognizing our number, and were enthusiastic, professional, and unbelievably swift to answer any question or to solve any issue. I love that the software is hosted (at least for us). A joy to not have to deal with local servers, network shares, etc.
CONS1 - long term - having 100% web based Advantage would be neat, but Citrix Receiver works perfectly on our Macs and PCs. 2 - The logins are a little weird (generic strings, rather than a custom username). Users will of course forget those, or write them on a sticky on their monitor (bad). We ended up making a chart of people's user logins and keep it in 1Password. Not a huge deal.
Eileen
Marketing and Advertising, 51-200 employees
Used daily for less than 12 months
OVERALL RATING:
4
EASE OF USE
4
VALUE FOR MONEY
4
CUSTOMER SUPPORT
5
FUNCTIONALITY
4
Reviewed March 2021
Switching to Advantage was a great choice
Working with the Advantage team has been an amazing experience. From implementation to training, and now through regular daily use the team at Advantage has been supportive, communicative, and always willing to help. Remote training was a fantastic option for us, and left us with amazingly detailed videos to reference as we began really working with the tool. Their support staff is patient, knowledgable and can easily help troubleshoot any issue faced. We are so thrilled with the level of customer support offered to us at every turn, even when the issues are clearly user errors.
PROSWhen switching to Advantage, we were looking for a tool that allowed us to more seamlessly integrate our billing, media and project management needs all in one platform. Prior to the switch much of our media billing needed to be manually entered into the system, as all buying took place on third party sites. With the switch to Advantage, we were able to integrate our media campaigns into the Advantage software, cutting down on the manual work needed in the billing process. Additionally, we loved the project management tools, and robust reporting capabilities available.
CONSAny new software implementation is a challenge. There is a lot of work that goes into the setup of Advantage because it is such a robust tool. Really understanding how all the pieces fit together for your business and for the systems daily use is very important and one that must be addressed at the start of the process. We are still learning all the aspects of the impacts of choices we made during implementation. With all that said, the advantage team has been with us every step of the way to help us maximize the tool for our agency. They are always open to software enhancements, and so any minor inconveniences we have faced they have heard our feedback on how to improve it for us.
Reasons for switching to Advantage
We were looking for a more fully integrated platform that allowed for more automated media buying.
Bethany
Marketing and Advertising, 51-200 employees
Used daily for less than 2 years
OVERALL RATING:
3
EASE OF USE
2
FUNCTIONALITY
3
Reviewed July 2019
Not User Friendly
I preferred working with ASANA
PROSWe've been told it is a better tool for us to track how many hours everyone is using and estimate time we will need for new projects.
CONSWe changed to this for project management and time tracking. It is one of the most frustrating interfaces I've ever seen. Nothing is intuitive. You have to click so many times to just get to the thing you need.
Vendor Response
Hi Bethany, Thanks for taking the time to share your experience. I'm disappointed that you're having frustrations. We released a major update to UX earlier this year and the response has been overwhelmingly positive, particularly on our time-sheet module. We want to make sure you're getting all the support you need to manage your day with our all-in-one agency management platform (Accounting, Project Management, Media). You have access to free training videos at http://usercommunity.gotoadvantage.com/, and I'd be happy to arrange for a free training call with one of our project management experts. Please feel free to respond to the notification email and I'll personally work with you to align the right resources. I'll also reach out to the designated contact at your agency to see if there's anything we can do to better support you.Looking forward to connecting! Best Regards, Jeff Thrall, CRO
Replied July 2019
Maria
Marketing and Advertising, 11-50 employees
Used daily for more than 2 years
OVERALL RATING:
5
EASE OF USE
5
VALUE FOR MONEY
5
CUSTOMER SUPPORT
5
FUNCTIONALITY
5
Reviewed September 2020
30+ years of Controller role and this is the very best product and customer service
I love Advantage. I have worked in other software systems (3) and implemented Advantage 2 times. You have found a way to have proper audit controls to help keep a company safe and knowledgeable in real time. I love your webinars and learning library, it allows us to grow on our own. But when we do have to call in for help, I am never disappointed by the knowledge and professionalism. Thank you
PROSIt is solid and performs as it should. Advantage make continuous helpful updates so it is relevant. The updates are painless. But what I like the best is the customer service. I have used this company for over 20 years and I have NEVER had a bad experience. Everyone has solid background of experience and is not only helpful but polite. We joke that we have learned more about proper process controls by using the system properly. The system makes it easy to perform work controls properly.
CONSWe are hosted - if we could export all the reports in excel or pdf easily (I have noticed many reports are being added and love it when we can email them).
Reason for choosing Advantage
I had already had experience with Advantage and knew how easy the implementation would be. You made me look like a rock star because we had so many new reports and capabilities.
Reasons for switching to Advantage
Workamajig was not set up properly and did a poor job with WIP (Advantage make is so clear and easy). Experienced long wait time responses and some of our employees had rude customer service when they were in training. Clients and Profits was old and was literally crashing, so we would have to run from back ups. I had already had experience with Advantage and knew how easy the implementation would be. You made me look like a rock star because we had so many new reports and capabilities.
Miles
Marketing and Advertising, 2-10 employees
Used daily for less than 6 months
OVERALL RATING:
5
EASE OF USE
3
VALUE FOR MONEY
4
CUSTOMER SUPPORT
5
FUNCTIONALITY
4
Reviewed July 2020
Great support team!
Our experience has been great. This is a great system to help organize and build your operation into the future!
PROSThe human component. They have a tremendous support team that really takes the time to understand your business and how you can most effectively benefit from the myriad of features both on setup and implementation. On the software side, there are a lot of options so you'll always be able to find a way to make it work the way you need it to.
CONSIt can be quite overwhelming and confusing. There are aspects of usability that I believe require more steps than necessary. However, this is often the case with software that's built to service a variety of business types and sizes. Again, I'll point out that their staff and support are phenomenal and even in times of confusion are right there with you to guide you through and get you effective solutions to the hurdles you're encountering.
Reason for choosing Advantage
We chose Advantage based on the comprehensive project management, media planning tools, and accounting system.
Anonymous
201-500 employees
Used daily for more than 2 years
OVERALL RATING:
4
EASE OF USE
3
VALUE FOR MONEY
4
CUSTOMER SUPPORT
5
FUNCTIONALITY
4
Reviewed June 2018
Administrator, trainer and support point of contact at my Agency for Advantage.
Automation for tedious work functions, workflow streamlined across departments, ease of use once you know the software. People appreciate the ease of the timesheet compared to other software programs. Nice dashboards and reporting offerings to get our data and metrics out quickly.
PROSThe breadth of offerings from this ERP system is fantastic, especially for an Agency to streamline their media, accounting, timesheets, project management, resource management and dynamic reporting functions. Their customer support is phenomenal as well and always willing to help my company out even if they don't agree with our setup or processes. They are always pushing out enhancements, new features and bug fixes which keeps you up-to-date and moving with technology.
CONSThere are some limitations to some of the functionality and features with this system that makes it aggravating to easily get some actions accomplished. Ex: timesheets could be easier to do if you could add multiple lines at one time or upload a spreadsheet or have an API tied to our other internal systems. We wish licensing was a little more affordable, especially if we had this hosted on premise at Advantage. The frequency of upgrading the system becomes a bit tedious to me but I understand it's needed.
Sarah
Marketing and Advertising, 11-50 employees
Used daily for more than 2 years
OVERALL RATING:
4
EASE OF USE
4
VALUE FOR MONEY
4
CUSTOMER SUPPORT
5
FUNCTIONALITY
4
Reviewed March 2020
Software
Depending on your comfort with new systems, it takes a while to feel comfortable getting around and using the software. When I first started using, I didn't have much instruction from the person using prior to me but luckily Advantage has really knowledgeable customer service people. I definitely didn't hesitate to call them but could have utilized other methods that are available for learning.
PROSFor the most part, this software is better than any I've used before. I'm not the most tech-oriented so it is relatively easy to use and intuitive. This software is very robust and we don't use it to its full capacity but would like to use more of its capability. Advantage has the best customer service people and availability that I've experienced in numerous software systems.
CONSFinding and running reports can be cumbersome as there are two sources for reports. I believe Advantage is phasing out one of them to be able to just use one. There are small things on certain reports that I would like to see but Advantage always seems open to hearing suggestions. Also, there are so many reports and ways/options, as well as custom reports, it's somewhat overwhelming.
Steve
Public Relations and Communications, 11-50 employees
Used daily for more than 2 years
OVERALL RATING:
4
EASE OF USE
4
VALUE FOR MONEY
4
CUSTOMER SUPPORT
4
FUNCTIONALITY
4
Reviewed November 2020
A few thoughts
It does what we need it to do and is fairly flexible when we want to do something "a little different".
CONSIt seems like their are patches and updates quite frequently. I get the need to fix data safety/security features, but minor updates to features or updates to features that we don't even use can be a bit annoying.
Reasons for switching to Advantage
Adman was acquired by Advantage, I believe.
Randall
Marketing and Advertising, 11-50 employees
Used daily for less than 2 years
OVERALL RATING:
4
EASE OF USE
3
VALUE FOR MONEY
4
CUSTOMER SUPPORT
4
FUNCTIONALITY
4
Reviewed May 2018
Positive ongoing
Greater project production management as well as financial management. It's great.
PROSConnecting project work history in the job notes with financial tracking, in addition the flow from job opening to estimating along with assigning work separate from "alerting" folks to changes once jobs are in process.
CONSAdjusting time constraints to keep files open, this may be "user error", Pulling producer time reports to break each out on specific jobs is cumbersome.
Kevin
Marketing and Advertising, 51-200 employees
Used daily for less than 6 months
OVERALL RATING:
4
EASE OF USE
3
VALUE FOR MONEY
3
CUSTOMER SUPPORT
3
FUNCTIONALITY
4
Reviewed October 2017
Excellent total agency management system that is fully customizable
This is a full-featured product that allows for numerous levels of customization. It provides all the project management tools including digital proofing (extra cost) required build a streamlined agency workflow. The accounting system is very robust as well with the flexibility to scale as our company grows.
CONSDue to the high level of customization, it does require a large upfront investment of time to get it properly setup. The accounting side of the product has an extremely outdated UI. It would be great if the accounting side was as user-friendly as the web-based project management side.
Michelle
Broadcast Media, 2-10 employees
Used daily for more than 2 years
OVERALL RATING:
5
EASE OF USE
3
VALUE FOR MONEY
5
CUSTOMER SUPPORT
5
FUNCTIONALITY
4
Reviewed October 2020
Advantage believes in upgrading and improving the software!
Advantage has been great to work with and continues to take customer feedback to make the product better. I highly recommend this software all agencies.
PROSAdvantage believes in upgrading and improving the software. Others in the space have not provided significant upgrades to their buying software and it shows. Advantage has a running list of improvements and asked for client input to ensure their products are user friendly! Their customer service is above the rest. The feature that has the most impact for our agency is the ability to filter in Broadcast Worksheet. The filtering options saves my agency time and money because I can filter by day-part, CPM and build my broadcast plans so much faster. I love that it calculates the reach and frequency for you even if you are buying a market where you do not subscribe to Nielsen or Comscore. This has been extremely useful in assisting the agency in getting new business! The reporting available is also a great resource!
CONSAgain, Advantage has a great customer service team so they have been able to find me a workaround for what I was trying to accomplish.
Reasons for switching to Advantage
Smartplus was being discontinued and we needed a reliable media planning software that was not overly expensive. Advantage fitted the bill because they are reasonably prices, amazing customer service and had more user-friendly features within the Broadcast Worksheet.
Karen
Verified reviewer
Public Relations and Communications, 51-200 employees
Used daily for less than 12 months
OVERALL RATING:
5
EASE OF USE
4
VALUE FOR MONEY
5
CUSTOMER SUPPORT
5
FUNCTIONALITY
5
Reviewed March 2019
Comprehensive Software designed for agencies
We are extremely happy with Advantage/Aqua! Billing clients used to take our accounting team 2-3 weeks. Now we can get invoice drafts done in just a few day with improved accuracy. Even after 5 months on the system, we continue to discover new capabilities and information that help us run the business.
PROSAdvantage has been specifically designed to fit the needs of a PR or Advertising agency. Its flexibility allowed us to adapt the software to support our existing processes. It's made our team more efficient and gives us much more insight into our business data and metrics. Project management capabilities improve communication, budgeting and scheduling across the organization. In a long career, Advantage has the best client support team with which I have ever worked! Calls are answered immediately, problems are addressed and the Advantage folks are a delight to work with. Even better, many of the customer support folks have worked at PR or advertising agencies so they really understand our challenges and can offer "best practices". Lastly, it is a cloud based system so our team can work from anywhere with no need for server access.
CONSThis is a complex system and the learning curve is steep. The first couple of months on the system were a real struggle (this is where that outstanding client support really comes in handy!). New users should be prepared that implementation is a big project that requires both dedicated resources and management support. Aqua, the program used by most agency staff, is a good user experience but the accounting system is old code and it looks & works like old code. Some of the menus are not very intuitive and it can take a while to figure out how to use them.
Rachel
Marketing and Advertising, 51-200 employees
Used daily for less than 2 years
OVERALL RATING:
2
EASE OF USE
3
CUSTOMER SUPPORT
1
FUNCTIONALITY
2
Reviewed February 2020
Outdated and not optimized for Mac
From a financial and timesheet perspective, Advantage is fine, but from a project management software system it was pretty rough
PROSThe financial part, like putting in PO's and invoices was easy to edit and go back to.
CONSThings just seemed overly complicated and the software wasn't optimized for Mac users so it was sometimes difficult to use.
Vendor Response
Hi Rachel, Thanks for your candid thoughts. I did a little research and it looks like you were using a now outdated version of our software. We're constantly updating and enhancing our agency management platform based on customer feedback. We actually did a major update to the project management system in April of 2019, which appears to be after you were using it. Our all-in-one agency management system is highly configurable to each client's specific workflow, so the experience each client has with it is also greatly affected by how your agency chooses to configure it for their specific environment. I should also note that we offer all of our users unlimited access to a live customer support line 12 hours a day, every business day, staffed by US-based agency vets who can help you through anything you may find complicated. Hopefully our paths will cross again and we can offer a better experience for you next time. Be well! Best Regards, Jeff Jeff Thrall, CRO
Replied February 2020
Lannie
Verified reviewer
Marketing and Advertising, 51-200 employees
Used daily for less than 2 years
OVERALL RATING:
5
EASE OF USE
5
VALUE FOR MONEY
5
CUSTOMER SUPPORT
5
FUNCTIONALITY
5
Reviewed April 2020
Advantage is highly customizable and gives you great insight
Advantage did a great job unifying us onto one accounting platform from two platforms and allowed us to move from five different project management platforms. Although set-up was complex and change was difficult after a year into using the product we are glad we switched and still learning new insights about our companies from the data we are collecting.
PROSWith a distributed workforce and five separate companies Advantage gives us great insight into financials and project management while allow.
CONSSet-up for Advantage to match our business was complex because our business is complex.
Dean
Information Technology and Services, 1 employee
Used weekly for less than 6 months
OVERALL RATING:
3
EASE OF USE
1
VALUE FOR MONEY
4
CUSTOMER SUPPORT
5
FUNCTIONALITY
4
Reviewed July 2019
Works well, but it's hard to set up.
Support is wonderful. The people behind the phone are great and always get what needs to done right away. Using the software has been difficult simply because it's a huge program that tries to do everything and as a result, it feels awkward and hobbled together. Training is non-existent unless you subscribe to the expensive training videos. Don't you already pay enough for the program to begin with? Having to work in Windows is a real downer and it's one of those programs that force people to run a specific operating system.
PROSFantastic customer support. Product is really flexible and customizable.
CONSThe product is Windows-only. Even though there's a web-based version of the software, you still need to use Windows to set some of the advanced features. The product is not well supported with detailed documentation and as such it's difficult to set up and learn. Advantage sells the service of installation to such a degree that they compete against their own documentation. As a result, training is placed behind an expensive paywall that must be purchased for as long as you use this product.
Reason for choosing Advantage
It's a legacy product that was used by the previous agency.
Vendor Response
Thanks for the feedback Dean; always appreciated. I've addressed a few key points below: 1)Platform-The product is not Windows-only. If self-hosting, the base runs on a Windows server, and admin settings are done there, but all user access is platform agnostic, as are all functions of the hosted platform. 2)System Documentation-The system has comprehensive documentation including step-by-step guides embedded throughout the system 3)System Setup-This is an enterprise-class system with a lot of capabilities. As such, it does require a little training and proper setup to fully leverage its power. 4) Training-Free training content is available at http://usercommunity.gotoadvantage.com/. Enhanced training is available for a nominal fee. Advantage trainers are available anytime, and customer support is available 12 hours a day, M-F for help. I'll send you a separate email with my personal contact information so we can make sure you have all the right info. Best-Jeff Thrall, CRO
Replied August 2019
Ann M.
Verified reviewer
Marketing and Advertising, 51-200 employees
Used daily for more than 2 years
OVERALL RATING:
5
EASE OF USE
4
FUNCTIONALITY
5
Reviewed October 2018
Using Advatage makes agency work easy
I used Advantage for the first time in my last job and had about 15 minutes of training and that's all I needed. At my current company, they didn't even train me when they learned I'd been in Advantage before. They let me figure it out on my own, even functionality I had not used before, and that was just fine
PROSThe ability to track hours, projects, and create jobs and purchase orders with this software is so easy and intuitive that I need almost no training in my last two positions to get up and running. I love that I can figure things out and basically train and trouble shoot for myself
CONSIt has so many more capabilities that I don't think our staff is using because we don't know what we don't know. Also, when an upgrade happens it can take a bit to get used to the new look and functionality, but isn't that true of any software?
Judith
Marketing and Advertising, 11-50 employees
Used daily for more than 2 years
OVERALL RATING:
5
EASE OF USE
5
VALUE FOR MONEY
5
CUSTOMER SUPPORT
5
FUNCTIONALITY
5
Reviewed July 2020
Advantage is a great product
Because our project management and media buying are linked to our accounting our financial reporting is far more accurate.
PROSWe have our project management, media planning and buying and accounting all in one package. The company is very proactive in keeping up with technology and the market.
CONSThat our server is on the eastern seaboard of the USA, and we are in NZ so there are timing issues with being able to contact support.
Reason for choosing Advantage
Advantage was the only product we found which combined project management, media planning and buying and accounting in one.
Reasons for switching to Advantage
We needed a product which could be accessed from anywhere in the world.
Anonymous
11-50 employees
Used daily for more than 2 years
OVERALL RATING:
5
EASE OF USE
4
VALUE FOR MONEY
5
CUSTOMER SUPPORT
5
FUNCTIONALITY