5 Best Business Project Management Solutions With Excellent Performance Ratings

by:
on October 30, 2019

When you use a software program every day, the last thing you want to deal with is slow load times or it crashing constantly. But how do you know about the performance without actually buying and using the product?

User reviews are the best place to start. And with thousands of reviews posted on our site, we thought we’d give you a jump start and narrow down the top 5 business project management products with the best reviews of their performance.

Performance gauges the capabilities of the software and if the product meets and/or exceeds expectations of reliability, speed, scalability, load times, etc. We take an objective look at these reviews and have calculated a “Sentiment Score” for each product in the project management software category.

What is a Sentiment Score?

Think of the Sentiment Score as a numerical representation of how real users rate and review it. The score is a rating of how positive the comments for a product or the features of a product are. Rave reviews get a higher score, lukewarm reviews a lower score, poor reviews get a negative score—all on a scale of 1 through 10.

The 5 best-performing business project management solutions

Presented in alphabetical order, here are the top 5 products with the highest performance sentiment across all reviewed project management solutions.

Product Performance Sentiment Score (out of 10)
Asana
6.36
Basecamp
6.39
ClickUp
6.50
Evernote Business
6.35
Todoist
6.57

Sentiment Score: 6.36 (out of a possible 10)

Mentions of performance in reviews: 116

Percent of mentions that are positive: 76%

Asana is a cloud-based project and task management solution that helps businesses manage and organize tasks and projects, communicate, and collaborate. It’s helpful for teams that handle multiple projects at one time, and it can serve companies of any size.

Users rated Asana’s performance only slightly higher than the category average, but the percent of negative comments is slim. With over 75% of the reviews praising the performance, it’s clear Asana offers a top performing product.

Asana performance review score

The Sentiment Score for Asana (out of a possible 10) as compared to all other products

Asana doesn’t currently have a native desktop app and some users commented this could improve the performance. But many didn’t say this was a full con, just something to know—which could help inform the slightly high percentage of neutral performance comments.

Asana user review sentiment

Click here to read some Asana reviews for yourself

Sentiment Score: 6.39 (out of a possible 10)

Mentions of performance in reviews: 232

Percent of mentions that are positive: 79%

Basecamp is a web-based solution, allowing users to sign in anywhere, any time, either through a web browser or through a mobile app. Basecamp is a real-time communication tool that helps teams stay on the same page; it’s less suited for traditional project management tasks (e.g., resource planning and long-term scheduling).

Basecamp ranks slightly higher than the average positive sentiment across all other project management tools. But with the lowest percent of negative sentiments shared, it’s clear Basecamp is offering excellent performance.

Basecamp performance review score

The Sentiment Score for Basecamp (out of a possible 10) as compared to all other products

Basecamp is the second product to have a very small percent of negative reviews, but a good chunk of neutral ones. But don’t let this overshadow the fact that they made our top 5 list and have over 75% positive reviews regarding performance.

Basecamp performance sentiment

Check out more details in the user reviews here

Sentiment Score: 6.50 (out of a possible 10)

Mentions of performance in reviews: 34

Percent of mentions that are positive: 76%

ClickUp is a cloud-based collaboration and project management tool suitable for businesses of all sizes and industries. Features include task assignments and statuses, alerts, and a task toolbar. Integrations include Slack and GitHub.

With a 6.5 Sentiment Score, ClickUp is clearly meeting the high-performance expectations of users. The stability during new releases and speed of integrations was a common theme in the reviews.

ClickUp performance review score

The Sentiment Score for ClickUp (out of a possible 10) as compared to all other products

While the vast majority of reviews are positive, there’s a roughly equal amount of neutral and negative reviews of ClickUp’s performance. Some reviewers noted Android app-specific or Chrome extension-specific pain points, but also mentioned the performance issues weren’t a constant problem.

ClickUp performance sentiment

You can read the individual reviews here

Sentiment Score: 6.35 (out of a possible 10)

Mentions of performance in reviews: 54

Percent of mentions that are positive: 82%

Evernote Business is a web-based business project management tool that offers project collaboration, scheduling, and task management all in one. This solution is designed to cater to businesses of all sizes.

Evernote supports multiple devices, such as laptops, tablets, and smartphones, which helps users across multiple locations stay on the same page and share project progress.

Evernote Business performance review score

The Sentiment Score for Evernote Business (out of a possible 10) as compared to all other products

Coming in with the second highest percentage of positive reviews, Evernote Business is proven to be meeting the performance needs of current users. Some reviewers commented on slow sync times to Google Docs or the mobile app crashing, but in general even these criticisms weren’t impacting their decision to continue using Evernote.

Evernote Business performance sentiment

Dive into the reviews for yourself here

Sentiment Score: 6.57 (out of a possible 10)

Mentions of performance in reviews: 21

Percent of mentions that are positive: 86%

Todoist is a project management solution available both for both cloud and on-premise deployment. It’s designed to meet the needs of midsize and small businesses. It’s optimized for tablets and smartphone devices via a mobile app.

Todoist has the top Sentiment Score across all other project management tools. While their sample size is on the smaller side, this shouldn’t diminish the importance of this stellar rating.

Todoist performance review score

The Sentiment Score for Todoist (out of a possible 10) as compared to all other products

Todoist also comes in with the largest percentage of positive sentiments on out list at 85%. A common theme in the reviews is that Todoist releases updates very quickly and that sometimes causes a bug or two. But the vendor is quick to release the fix. Not a bad problem to have!

Todoist performance sentiment

Want more info on Todoist? Click here

Additional resources for your software search

Our Project Management Software Buyer’s Guide has tons of info on common features, side-by-side product comparisons, and market trends you should know about.

Curious to know how users rated the customer service of project management software? Check out the Reviews Insight piece with the top 4 products here.

And of course, our expert advisors are here to help walk you through the software search. Fill out this form to get started with a quick, free consultation to narrow down your options.


Methodology

To be considered for inclusion in this report, we required 20 or more unique reviews mentioning “performance” or related terms.

The products listed in this report had the highest percentage of positive mentions of performance of eligible products.

To calculate Sentiment Score, we looked at the specific mentions of performance in each review and analyzed the terms used to describe performance. We then scored each term on a scale of 1 – 10, with 10 being the most positive, 5 being neutral, and 0 being the most negative. The score for each snippet was the sum of all descriptive terms in the snippet. Snippet scores were then averaged for the product to determine average Sentiment Score for the product.

When comparing the average Sentiment Score of a product to the average score for the entire category, the product’s score was removed for accuracy.

You may also like

How To Get Your Team To Collaborate Using Your PM Tool

How to Improve Project Communication Management Across the Project Lifecycle

4 Best Project Management Solutions With Excellent Customer Support Ratings

Compare project management software