Combat These 5 Major Causes of Donor Fatigue

As a small-to-midsize nonprofit, what’s your biggest fear? Is it high overhead costs? Losing out on donation money to other charities? Finding a solution to the problem you’re trying to solve and having world peace break out as a result?

GIF - I really do want world peace

OK, it’s probably not that last one

Whatever your major concerns are currently, here’s one that should rate highly: donor fatigue, the term for the diminished response by donors to needy causes as those causes never seem to improve.

More frequent requests for donations in the wake of this diminished response only compound the issue, adding to the levels of fatigue.

Poorly managed donor fatigue can contribute to non-profits losing over a third of their donors.

According to a report from the Fundraising Effectiveness Project, the retention rate of first-time donors is 19 percent, while the retention-rate of repeat donors is 63 percent, showing how important it is to both avoid donor fatigue and retain first-time donors.

If giant international issues like hurricane relief and war reconstruction suffer from donor fatigue, then so can your nonprofit.

Nonprofits can’t afford to lose supporters to donor fatigue, and thus they must implement deliberate responses to address their causes.

1. Nearly 100% of Disconnected Donors Don’t Contribute

Imagine going to the grocery store in order to buy some fruits and vegetables. However, instead of being able to shop for what you want, your only option is to purchase a big box marked “fresh produce,” with no clue about which actual product you’ll be getting or the benefits you’ll gain from them.

JJ Abrams with his mystery box

That might be how J.J. Abrams shops for groceries

This is what your donors feel like when they’re kept out of the loop in regards to how their money is spent after they donate. They want details about the “product” that your organization is providing, which in this case consist of the good work that you’re doing.

According to Rick Cohen, chief communications officer and chief operating officer of the National Council of Nonprofits, “People give because they believe in the work and the mission of the nonprofit. Continuing to keep that connection front-and-center helps keep donors.”

“You can accomplish this connection, Cohen suggests, by, “staying in regular (but not overwhelming) contact with past donors. Help keep them connected to the work of the nonprofit and let them know how their contributions make a difference.”

In practice, this means creating a regular newsletter mixing solid information about tangible results with powerful images in order to keep your donors informed about the ways in which their money is making a difference in the community that you serve.

Sending out only year-end appeals for more money won’t create the ongoing connection that your regular donors crave, and might even turn them off as being crass and exploitative.

Similarly, sending out too-frequent requests will lead donors to think that what they’ve given in the past isn’t appreciated, which will make them far less likely to donate in the future.

You need to find the proper cadence that will keep your donors informed without inundating them with appeals for their hard-earned money.

Pamela Stoikopoulos, senior communications and public relations manager at VHA Home HealthCare, gives some specific recommendations on what you can do to create a connection with your donors:

“Share success stories. It could be a first-person account of how your organization made a positive difference in someone’s life, for example. Take a multi-pronged approach.

Newsletters and blog articles are always great ways to stay in touch with your donors and share successes, but more and more of us are gravitating to video content as well. It doesn’t have to be big budget to be impactful.”

How to combat this cause of donor fatigue:

  1. Identify a good cadence of “results reporting” to sets of donors.
  2. Emphasize activities and results over pleas for contributions.
  3. Provide engaging content with pictures and video so donors become part of the action and feel ownership of the success.
  4. Make a softer request for additional contributions in the context of maintaining the success of current projects or the start of promising new projects.

2. No Visuals = No Engagement (And Lost Donors)

Your donors don’t just want to read about how their money is used, they want to see the impact that they’re making in action. Take lots of quality photos and videos of your work so that you can share it with your donors later.

VHS Home HealthCare blog with multiple images

VHA Home HealthCare regularly updates the company’s blog, using multiple images of their employees and the people whom they serve

Neel Somani of Cal Blueprint notes that, “the nonprofits that take pictures and videos of their work are the best at maintaining a steady flow of donations. The reason is simple. People like to be reminded that their dollar is being used effectively, and imagery is a great way to do that.”

Doctors Without Borders landing page

Doctors Without Borders’ main web-page is word-light and image-heavy

How to combat this cause of donor fatigue:

  1. Show and tell for the greatest impact.
  2. Use visuals to emotionally move and motivate donors.
  3. Emphasize the results you’ve achieved with before and after photos.
  4. Use video to make donors feel like they are present and a part of the action.

3. Fundraising Events are No Fun (Which Means No Funds)

Just like your donors don’t want to only hear from you at the end of the year when you want money, they also don’t want to only be invited to meet with you when you’re chasing after their wallets.

Instead, consider hosting events where you aren’t solely asking for money, like volunteer opportunities or even just information sessions, where your supporters can meet one another and inform others about your nonprofit’s good works.

Steve Johns, CEO of OneCause suggests that you “try mixing it up and planning a handful of events where supporters can attend without making a donation or where donations are not the primary focus of the event.

“Encourage donors to invite friends … or give them the option to organize a table of their supporters at an event. This will give your supporters the opportunity to show their friends and family that they are involved with a cause that they deeply care about and want to support.”

This will have the benefit of not only fighting back against current donors’ fatigue, but also helping to spread your message out to new prospects who might become donors, themselves.

How to combat this cause of donor fatigue:

  1. Hold regular events, not just annual fundraisers.
  2. Ensure that your events are informative and fun.
  3. Make donors feel like co-hosts of your events, not just names on a guest list.
  4. Turn your donors into ambassadors of your cause.

4. Donors You Don’t Track Can Leave Without You Even Knowing

If you’re just accepting money from your donors without also taking down important information that will enable you to keep track of them, then you’re only doing half the job.

Donors’ crucial data extends beyond the number of dollars they spend.

According to James Citron, CEO of Pledgeling, a digital platform enabling businesses to support nonprofits, you should also be able to track:

  • Track particular goals for each donor
  • Track channels through which donors wish to be engaged
  • Share updates about the nonprofit’s impact with custom messages based on donor interests

This data will enable you to keep up that crucial ongoing relationship with your donors.

As Rick Cohen further explains, “tracking in a database that one donor feels a personal connection to the job training program and another feels more of a connection with the housing program can allow that nonprofit to send out more specific updates related to the work that matters most to a particular donor.

“It also helps ensure a donor doesn’t unsubscribe from updates when they see a bunch of emails on a program they don’t feel as strongly about.”

A donor database dashboard as it appears in Kindful
 

This is why it’s important you keep track of your donors’ preferences and motivations—if you can target communications to them, you’re less likely to overwhelm them with content that turns them off rather than drawing them in.

How to combat this cause of donor fatigue:

  1. Whenever somebody donates money, take down their contact information.
  2. Keep track of donors’ information and preferences.
  3. Track interactions that anybody at your organization has with each donor.
  4. Consider investing in a nonprofit CRM (constituent relationship management) software system to help you track all of this data.

5. Letting Donors Go Without Asking ‘Why’ Means You’ll Never Do Better

No matter how much you fight against it, chances are that you’re always going to lose some recurring donors to fatigue and other causes. However, if you just let them go without any further inquiry, you’re missing out on crucial information that can prevent such a thing from happening in the future.

Alexander Lowry, executive director of the Master of Science in Financial Analysis program at Gordon College, advises that, “When you lose a donor to suspected donor fatigue, investigate the details of the situation to find out if there was anything in particular the organization may have done, or not done, to cause it.

“They will feel valued for having been consulted and ultimately depart (or not!) with a more positive perception of the nonprofit. You may find some simple answers to help prevent this from happening again.”

Remember, even when you lose a donor you might be able to win them back, and gaining information about why they’re experiencing fatigue is the only way you can create positive changes that will help alter their decision and prevent others like them from also taking their money elsewhere.

How to combat this cause of donor fatigue:

  1. Debrief departing donors to get honest feedback from them.
  2. Pinpoint the reason for donors’ distress.
  3. Make specific and immediate changes to fix that particular issue.
  4. Reach out to lost donors and see if you can get them back on board after you’ve implemented these changes.

Summary: Steps to Take to Fight Donor Fatigue

Congratulations! You now have the tools you need to fight back against the biggest causes of donor fatigue. Keep these five tips in mind if you want your recurring donors to stick around:

  1. Keep in touch with your donors regularly (but not excessively), providing them with content that shows them how their money is being spent.
  2. Use less text and more images.
  3. Hold regular donor-focused events to spread the message of your organization and not just ask for money.
  4. Track your donors’ information in a nonprofit CRM system.
  5. Get feedback from departing donors about what they’re unhappy with and make changes accordingly.

Most importantly, remember that one of the main causes of fatigue is asking for donations far too frequently. Make sure you’re mixing appeals for money with other forms of content to form a relationship with your donors, so that asking for money seems like one part of a much richer partnership.

Now, if you’re not too fatigued yourself, here’s some other steps you can take to help your nonprofit grow and thrive:

You may also like

How to Build a Stronger Nonprofit Marketing Plan to Reach More Donors

How to Get Nonprofit Software Discounts

Nonprofit Best Practices: How to Improve Your Organization With Software

How to Improve Nonprofit Donor Retention Strategies