Buddy Punch vs Jibble: Which is best for you?

I like being able to punch in and out from my phone, make changes to my punch times if needed, and request days and time off on my own.

Unable to have two different pay schedules requiring an off cycle payroll every pay period for my salaried employees.

Jibble's free version has enough features for our small private medical practice to easily track employee hours and has the ability to integrate with QuickBooks.

In particular, having to pay for custom work periods is frustrating, as this feels like a basic requirement rather than a premium feature. While the free version is good for simple tracking, it becomes limiting once you need even modest flexibility.